The BMW i5: A Modern Marvel or Just Another Electric Gizmo?

3.9 / 5
BMW i5 (2024)
Comfort
8.5
Performance
7.8
Value
7.0
Reliabiliy
8.0
Author
Oliver Jenkins
August 15th, 2025
As a former GT3 racing driver who spent countless hours at the wheel of some of the most ferocious machines on legendary circuits like Le Mans and Daytona, I've always been drawn to the raw, unfiltered thrill of driving. The roar of a finely-tuned engine, the tactile feedback through the steering wheel, and the delicate dance between throttle and brake—these are the elements that have defined my life behind the wheel. But times are changing, and the automotive world is evolving at an electrifying pace. Enter the BMW i5, an electric sedan that promises to deliver both performance and eco-friendliness. It's a bold claim, and one that I approach with a mixture of excitement and skepticism. Will the i5 manage to bridge the gap between the visceral excitement of traditional motoring and the quiet efficiency of electric power? Join me as I take this modern marvel on a journey through the breathtaking landscapes of the Scottish Highlands to find out if it truly lives up to the hype.
The BMW i5: A Modern Marvel or Just Another Electric Gizmo?

Setting Off: The Journey Begins

I decided to take the new BMW i5 on a trip across the picturesque landscapes of the Scottish Highlands. Yes, Scotland, where the roads are as unpredictable as the weather and the scenery is a stark reminder of the beauty that exists outside of concrete jungles. The i5, with its sleek design and something that BMW calls 'minimalistic luxury', seemed like the perfect companion for this journey.

The First Impressions: Aesthetic and Interior

Sliding into the i5, you are greeted by an interior that screams 'modern'. It's all digital displays and touch-sensitive everything, which is fine if you're trying to impress a tech-savvy crowd. But there's something about a good old-fashioned button that just can't be replicated. The seats, however, offered comfort akin to a plush leather armchair in a gentleman's club, which is precisely where I'd rather be if I wasn't about to embark on this journey.

On the Road: Performance and Handling

Now, onto what really matters. Performance. The i5, despite its electric innards, manages to conjure some semblance of what I'd call 'driving pleasure'. The electric motor delivers power in a linear fashion that is, admittedly, quite addictive. There's no lag, no hesitation, just pure, unadulterated forward momentum. It's like being strapped to a catapult, except without the noise and drama that usually accompanies such experiences.

Handling, too, is surprisingly sharp. The i5 dances through the bends with the grace of a seasoned ballerina, though I suspect this is more the result of clever engineering and less the car's inherent spirit. The steering is precise, though it lacks the tactile feedback of yesteryear's hydraulic systems. Still, it's commendable for an electric car, which is saying something.

The Scenic Route: Highlands Adventures

As I navigated the winding roads of the Highlands, the i5 proved to be a capable companion. The car's range held up admirably, though I did have visions of being stranded amidst the heather and thistle with nothing but my thoughts and a rapidly depleting battery. Thankfully, such a scenario did not unfold.

The scenery was, of course, breathtaking. Rugged cliffs, serene lochs, and the occasional sighting of a Highland cow provided ample distraction from the i5's incessant beeping and flashing warnings. Technology, it seems, cannot resist the urge to remind you of its presence at every opportunity.

A Moment of Reflection: The End of the Journey

As my journey drew to a close, I found myself contemplating the i5's place in the automotive world. It is, undoubtedly, a marvel of modern engineering. It offers a glimpse into a future where cars are as much about technology as they are about transportation. But I can't help but feel a pang of nostalgia for the days when driving was a visceral experience, not an exercise in digital proficiency.

In the end, the BMW i5 is a car that straddles the line between the past and the future. It's a nod to the environmentally conscious, yet it retains enough of the driving dynamics to keep purists like myself mildly entertained. So, is it a modern marvel or just another electric gizmo? Perhaps it's a bit of both, and maybe that's just what the world needs right now.

As I returned the i5 to its rightful owners, I couldn't help but wonder what the future holds for us motoring enthusiasts. Perhaps one day, we'll all be zipping around in silent, battery-powered machines, reminiscing about the roar of a V8 and the smell of burning rubber. Until then, I'll keep searching for the perfect balance between the old and the new, one journey at a time.



Ah, the BMW i5 (2024). A car that, much like your grandmother's antique teapot, attempts to blend the old with the new. It's a valiant effort to marry the thrill of driving with the eco-consciousness of today's world. And yet, as I sit in this digital cockpit, I find myself yearning for a time when cars spoke in the language of pistons and petrol rather than pixels and apps. The i5 is indeed a marvel of modern engineering, with its whisper-quiet electric motor and a range that could take you from London to the Scottish Highlands without so much as a hiccup. But, the tactile feedback of a hydraulic steering system is sorely missed, much like the manual gearbox in a world gone automatic. The handling is precise, yet lacks the visceral thrill of its petrol predecessors. In the end, the i5 is a competent vehicle, a nod to the future of motoring, while simultaneously serving as a reminder of what we've left behind. It's a car that will no doubt appeal to those who value a seamless integration of technology and transportation. But for those of us who still get misty-eyed at the sound of a roaring V8, it's a reminder that the soul of driving is slowly slipping away.

Specifications

SpecificationValue
EngineElectric
Horsepower335
Torque295 lb-ft
0-60 mph5.7 seconds
Top speed120 mph
Range300 miles
Battery capacity80 kWh
Charging time10 hours (Level 2)
Drive typeRear-wheel drive
Seating capacity5
Curb weight4,750 lbs